How do I know if my car battery should be replaced?

Reviving Your Car Battery: How to Fix a Dead Cell

03/01/2009

Rating: 4.1 (15816 votes)

A car battery is the heart of your vehicle's electrical system, providing the necessary jolt to start the engine and power all your onboard electronics. Just like any vital component, it has a finite lifespan, typically ranging from four to six years. However, sometimes batteries can fail much sooner than expected, and often, the cause points to a single, ailing cell within. Understanding what a car battery cell is, why it might die, and crucially, how to potentially fix it, can save you a significant amount of money and hassle. While a full battery replacement is always an option, a dead cell doesn't always spell the end for your existing power pack.

Can a car battery work with a dead cell?
No, a car battery cannot work with a dead cell. When one of the cells in your car battery dies, it is unable to produce enough power to keep your vehicle running and will need to be replaced or recharged.

The individual cells within your car battery are miniature powerhouses, each contributing to the overall voltage and amperage required to operate your vehicle. When one of these cells falters, the entire battery's performance is compromised, often leading to a frustrating no-start situation. But what exactly constitutes a 'dead' or 'damaged' cell, and is it truly possible to bring it back from the brink? Let's delve into the mechanics of battery failure and explore a surprisingly simple at-home remedy.

Table

What Is a Dead or Damaged Cell?

At its core, a dead or dying cell is one that can no longer produce its share of electricity. In a typical 12-volt car battery, there are six individual cells, each designed to produce approximately 2.1 volts. When one of these cells fails to generate its expected voltage, the overall battery voltage drops, making it incapable of delivering the necessary power to crank the engine. This is one of the most prevalent reasons for battery failure and a common source of roadside breakdowns.

Cell death isn't always a sudden event; it can be a gradual decline. While natural ageing is a primary factor, where the internal components simply wear out, other causes can accelerate the process. Leaving your car's lights on overnight, or any other parasitic drain on the battery when the engine isn't running, can deeply discharge the battery, pushing cells beyond their recovery point. This deep discharge can lead to the formation of lead sulphate crystals on the battery plates, a process known as sulfation, which is a leading cause of premature battery failure. Once severe, sulfation can physically block the chemical reactions needed to produce electricity, effectively 'killing' the cell.

Signs Your Car Battery (or a Cell) Is Dying

Before you panic and assume the worst, it's crucial to correctly diagnose whether your battery is indeed the problem, or if another component is at fault. Here are some key indicators that suggest your car battery, or one of its vital cells, is on its way out:

  • Slow Engine Crank: This is arguably the most common symptom. If your engine sounds sluggish or takes longer than usual to turn over, especially when the weather isn't particularly cold, it's a strong sign your battery isn't delivering enough power.
  • Headlights and Power, But No Start: You might have power for your radio and dashboard lights, but when you turn the key, you hear nothing or just a single click. This indicates that there's enough residual power for low-drain electronics, but not enough amperage to engage the starter motor.
  • Clicking Sound When Turning the Key: A rapid clicking noise from under the bonnet often means the starter solenoid is trying to engage but isn't receiving enough power from the battery to fully turn the engine.
  • Radio or Electronics Malfunction: If your ignition is in the 'ON' position and your radio, electric windows, or other accessories don't power up, or behave erratically, it points to insufficient battery voltage.
  • Swollen or Bulging Battery Case: Visually inspect your battery. If the case appears swollen or distorted, it could be a sign of overcharging, often due to a faulty alternator. Overcharging generates excessive heat and hydrogen gas, which can warp the battery case and damage internal cells.
  • Unpleasant Odour: A strong smell akin to rotten eggs (sulphur) emanating from your battery is a serious red flag. This indicates the battery is venting excess hydrogen sulphide gas, often due to overcharging or internal short circuits. It also suggests that sulphuric acid may have been released, which can corrode surrounding engine components.
  • Age of the Battery: If your battery is approaching or has exceeded its average lifespan of 4-6 years, it's simply reaching the end of its natural life. Components degrade over time, leading to reduced capacity.
  • Illuminated Check Engine Light: While this light can signify a multitude of issues, it can sometimes be triggered by a dying battery. The car's computer may detect low voltage, flagging it as an engine problem.
  • Engine Starts Then Immediately Dies: In some rare cases, a battery might have just enough voltage to briefly engage the starter, but then immediately dies because it lacks the sustained power to keep the engine idling. This can also be indicative of other underlying vehicle faults, so further investigation may be required.

If you've performed these checks and suspect a faulty battery, it's wise to address it promptly to prevent potential damage to other electrical components in your vehicle.

Causes of a Bad Cell in a Car Battery

Understanding the root causes of cell failure can help you prolong your battery's life. Beyond natural ageing, several factors contribute to a cell's demise:

  • Deep Discharging: As mentioned, repeatedly draining your battery completely, perhaps by leaving lights on or through long periods of inactivity, is detrimental. Each deep discharge cycle reduces the battery's overall capacity and encourages sulfation.
  • Sulfation: This is the most common culprit. When a battery is undercharged or left discharged for extended periods, lead sulphate crystals form on the lead plates within the cells. These crystals harden over time, becoming an electrical insulator that prevents the battery from charging or discharging effectively.
  • Overcharging: A faulty voltage regulator or alternator can cause the battery to be constantly overcharged. This leads to excessive heat, boiling of the electrolyte, and corrosion of the positive plates, ultimately damaging the cells and causing the battery to swell.
  • Vibration and Physical Damage: Constant vibrations from driving, especially if the battery isn't securely mounted, can cause the internal plates to break or short-circuit. Impact from an accident can also damage cells.
  • Manufacturing Defects: Occasionally, a cell may have an inherent flaw from the factory, leading to premature failure. This can include issues with plate alignment or impurities in the lead.
  • Extreme Temperatures: Both extreme heat and cold can impact battery health. High temperatures accelerate corrosion and evaporation of electrolyte, while very low temperatures reduce the battery's capacity and make it harder to deliver current, stressing the cells.

Can a Car Battery Work With a Dead Cell?

In short, no. A car battery cannot effectively work with a dead cell. Even if only one cell out of the six is compromised, the entire battery's performance is severely affected. The dead cell acts like an open circuit or a high resistance point, preventing the full flow of current and significantly reducing the overall voltage. This means the battery will be unable to produce the high amperage required to crank your engine. Furthermore, a dead cell often becomes a drain on the remaining healthy cells, pulling them down and accelerating their degradation. Attempting to charge or jump-start a battery with a dead cell is often futile, as it simply won't hold a charge or deliver sufficient power.

Can a Dead Battery Cell Be Revived?

The good news is, sometimes, yes! While not every dead cell can be brought back to life, particularly if it's due to an internal short circuit or severe physical damage, many cases of sulfation-induced cell death can be reversed. The Epsom salt solution method, detailed below, is a popular DIY approach that aims to break down the sulphate crystals and restore the cell's ability to conduct electricity. However, it's crucial to understand that this is a repair, not a permanent fix, and the battery's overall lifespan may still be shortened.

How to Fix a Dead or Damaged Cell in a Car Battery: The Epsom Salt Method

If you've identified a dead cell and are ready to attempt a repair, this method offers a straightforward approach. Always prioritise safety when working with car batteries, as they contain corrosive acid and can produce explosive gases. Ensure you are in a well-ventilated area, wear appropriate eye protection and gloves, and avoid any sparks or open flames.

What can cause a car battery cell to die?
A dead or dying cell is when there is not enough electricity being produced in order to power the battery. This is one of the most common reasons for dying batteries. Dying cells can happen naturally when there is no support for the cell to adapt or because of aging but it can also happen after you leave your lights on when the car isn’t running.

Essentials You'll Need:

  • Epsom salts (Magnesium Sulphate)
  • Distilled water
  • Baking soda (Sodium Bicarbonate)
  • Voltmeter
  • Screwdriver (flathead, often)
  • Funnel
  • Battery charger (preferably one with a low amperage setting)
  • Bucket
  • Safety glasses and chemical-resistant gloves

Step-by-Step Guide:

  1. Prepare the Epsom Salt Solution: In a well-ventilated area, mix half a quart (approximately 470ml) of distilled water with eight ounces (approximately 225g) of Epsom salt. Gently heat the mixture until the Epsom salt is completely dissolved. Do not boil.
  2. Clean the Battery Terminals: Before doing anything else, disconnect the battery from your vehicle (negative terminal first, then positive). Use a mixture of baking soda and water to thoroughly clean any corrosion from the battery terminals and case. Corrosion can impede electrical flow and indicate acid leakage. Rinse with clean water and dry completely.
  3. Assess Battery Health with a Voltmeter: Connect your voltmeter to the battery terminals. A reading below 10 volts typically indicates that the battery is severely discharged or has irreparable damage, and a full replacement might be the only viable option. If it reads higher, proceed to the next step.
  4. Access the Battery Cells: Most traditional lead-acid car batteries have removable cell caps. Using a flathead screwdriver, carefully pry open the top cover of the battery (if it has one) to expose the individual cell caps. Then, remove each cell cap. Be gentle to avoid damaging them.
  5. Empty the Old Electrolyte: Place the battery in a bucket. Carefully tip the battery to empty the old electrolyte fluid from each cell into the bucket. The baking soda in the bucket will help neutralise the acid. Be extremely cautious as battery acid is highly corrosive.
  6. Refill with Epsom Salt Solution: Using a funnel, carefully pour the prepared Epsom salt solution into each cell until the plates are just covered, or to the marked fill line if present. Do not overfill.
  7. Seal and Shake: Replace all the cell caps and then the main battery cover. Gently shake the battery for about a minute. This helps to ensure the Epsom salt solution is evenly distributed and can penetrate the plates.
  8. Recharge the Battery: Connect your battery charger. For best results with a desulfation attempt, charge the battery at a low amperage (e.g., 2 amps) for an extended period, typically 24 to 36 hours. This slow charge allows the Epsom salt solution to work effectively on breaking down the sulphate crystals.
  9. Install and Test: Once fully charged, reconnect the battery to your vehicle (positive terminal first, then negative). Attempt to start your car. If successful, take it for a short test drive to allow the alternator to further charge and condition the battery.

Important Considerations:

  • This method is most effective for batteries suffering from sulfation due to undercharging or disuse. It is unlikely to work for batteries with physically damaged plates, shorted cells, or those that have been completely dry for a long time.
  • Always dispose of old battery acid and batteries responsibly at a certified recycling centre.
  • If the repair doesn't work, a new battery is your safest and most reliable option.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What Happens If You Have a Dead Cell in Your Car Battery?

If you have a dead cell in your car battery, the battery's overall voltage will drop significantly, typically below the 12.6 volts needed for a healthy 12V battery. This means it cannot produce the necessary amperage to crank and start your vehicle's engine. Even if only one cell is dead, the entire battery becomes effectively useless for starting the car, forcing you to either replace the entire battery or attempt a repair on the individual cell.

Can You Charge a Battery With a Dead Cell?

While you can connect a charger to a battery with a dead cell, it will generally not hold a charge effectively, nor will it bring the dead cell back to life through conventional charging. The compromised cell will often prevent the battery from reaching its full voltage potential, and it may even drain the charge from the healthy cells around it. Jump-starting such a battery is also usually futile, as it won't be able to retain the charge or provide sustained power.

Can You Fix a Shorted Battery Cell in a Car Battery?

Unfortunately, shorted battery cells are typically not repairable. A short circuit within a cell is often caused by physical damage, such as plates touching due to vibration or manufacturing defects, or by severe sulfation that has formed a conductive bridge. Once a short occurs, the cell's ability to produce voltage is permanently compromised, and the only reliable solution is to replace the entire battery.

Can You Use Vinegar to Clean a Car Battery?

Yes, vinegar can be used to clean corrosion from car battery terminals. A mixture of vinegar and baking soda creates a fizzing reaction that effectively neutralises and loosens the corrosive buildup. Simply apply the mixture, let it sit for a few minutes while it fizzes, and then use a wire brush to scrub away the residue. Rinse thoroughly with clean water and ensure the battery is completely dry before reconnecting. Always disconnect the battery terminals before cleaning.

How Do You Revive a Car Battery That Won't Hold a Charge?

If your car battery won't hold a charge, first, ensure the terminals are clean and connections are secure. Then, test each individual cell with a voltmeter (if accessible). If any cell reads significantly lower than 2 volts, it may be dead or severely sulfated. For batteries that are just deeply discharged or lightly sulfated, a slow, extended charge (often called a 'trickle charge' or 'desulfation charge') for 24-48 hours can sometimes revive them. If individual cells are accessible, you might try the Epsom salt method described above. However, if the battery still refuses to hold a charge after these attempts, it's likely beyond repair and needs replacement.

Conclusion

The sudden failure of a car battery, especially due to a dead cell, can be an incredibly frustrating experience. However, as we've explored, it doesn't always have to lead to an immediate and costly replacement. Understanding the symptoms of a dying battery and, more specifically, the causes of a dead cell, empowers you to make informed decisions.

For many common instances of cell failure, particularly those caused by sulfation, a simple and inexpensive DIY fix using Epsom salts and distilled water can breathe new life into your battery. By following our step-by-step guide, you can potentially restore your battery's functionality and get your vehicle back on the road in no time. While this method isn't a guaranteed solution for every type of battery damage, it's a worthwhile attempt that can save you a significant amount of money and provide a rewarding sense of accomplishment. Remember, safety first, and if in doubt, consult a professional mechanic.

If you want to read more articles similar to Reviving Your Car Battery: How to Fix a Dead Cell, you can visit the Maintenance category.

Go up