MOT Failures: Can a Chip Cause an MOT Failure?

Understanding MOT Failures and Vehicle Electronics

The annual MOT test is a crucial part of ensuring your vehicle is safe and roadworthy. While many drivers are familiar with common failure points like worn tyres, faulty brakes, or broken lights, the role of modern vehicle electronics can sometimes be a grey area. A common question that arises is: 'Can a chip fail an MOT?' This query often stems from a misunderstanding of what a 'chip' refers to in the context of a car and how the MOT test assesses vehicle systems.

In the automotive world, 'chip' can refer to several different things, from a small piece of damaged metal or plastic to the sophisticated electronic control units (ECUs) that manage virtually every aspect of a modern vehicle's performance and safety. The key to answering whether a 'chip' can cause an MOT failure lies in clarifying which type of chip we are discussing and how it impacts the vehicle's compliance with MOT regulations.

What is an 'MOT Chip'? Clarifying the Terminology

When people ask about a 'chip' failing an MOT, they are usually referring to one of two main things:

• Physical Damage: This could be a small chip or crack in a windscreen, a chip in the paintwork, or even a small piece of plastic trim that has broken off.
• Electronic Control Units (ECUs) / Software Tuning ('Chipping'): This refers to the computerised systems within the car, and in some cases, modifications made to the engine's software to improve performance.

Let's break down how each of these can, or cannot, affect your MOT outcome.

Physical Chips and the MOT Test

The MOT test has specific criteria for assessing damage to various components. When it comes to physical chips, the most common concern is with the windscreen.

Windscreen Chips: A Common MOT Concern

The MOT test manual specifies strict rules regarding damage to a vehicle's windscreen. The primary concern is visibility and structural integrity. According to the DVSA (Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency), a chip on the windscreen can cause an MOT failure if:

• It is in the driver's direct line of sight.
• It is larger than 10mm in diameter within the 'zone A' area (the area swept by the wipers).
• It is larger than 40mm in diameter outside the driver's direct line of sight.
• It is a crack that extends into the 'A' zone.

Why is this important? A damaged windscreen can impair the driver's vision, creating a significant safety hazard. It can also weaken the structural integrity of the vehicle's body, particularly the area around the windscreen, which is crucial for occupant protection in a collision.

Other Physical Chips

While a chipped windscreen is a definite MOT failure risk, other minor physical chips are less likely to cause a fail unless they create a safety issue. For instance:

• Paint Chips: Small chips in the paintwork are generally not an MOT failure point. However, if the rust resulting from paint chips is severe enough to compromise structural integrity (e.g., on the chassis or body panels in critical areas), it could lead to a fail.
• Plastic Trim Chips: Minor chips in plastic trim pieces (like bumper corners or mirror casings) are unlikely to fail an MOT unless they become loose, sharp, or pose a hazard to pedestrians or other vehicles.

Electronic Chips: ECUs and Software Tuning

This is where the term 'chip' can become more complex. Modern vehicles rely heavily on Electronic Control Units (ECUs), often referred to as 'chips' or 'computers'. These ECUs manage everything from engine performance and emissions to braking systems and lighting. Software tuning, often called 'chipping' or 'remapping', involves altering the software within the ECU to change how the engine operates.

Can ECU Software Tuning ('Chipping') Cause an MOT Fail?

Directly, the act of 'chipping' an ECU for performance gains does not inherently cause an MOT failure. However, the *consequences* of such modifications can certainly lead to a fail. The MOT test has stringent requirements regarding emissions and engine performance.

Emissions: If an ECU remap results in your vehicle exceeding the legally permitted emission levels for its age and type, it will fail the emissions part of the MOT. This is a very common outcome if the remap is not done carefully or if it's an aggressive tune.

Engine Management Light (EML): If a remap or any other ECU issue causes the Engine Management Light (or Malfunction Indicator Lamp - MIL) to illuminate on the dashboard, this is an automatic MOT fail. The EML indicates a fault within the engine management system, and the MOT tester is required to check for this.

Performance Issues: While not directly tested in the same way as emissions, a poorly executed remap could lead to erratic engine behaviour, stalling, or other performance issues that might be indirectly detected during the test, especially if they affect the vehicle's ability to be safely driven or tested on rollers.

Faulty ECUs and Other Electronic 'Chips'

Beyond software tuning, the physical ECUs themselves can fail. If an ECU fails in a way that affects critical safety or emissions systems, it can lead to an MOT failure. For example:

• ABS/ESP Warning Lights: If the ECU responsible for the Anti-lock Braking System (ABS) or Electronic Stability Programme (ESP) malfunctions, the warning light will illuminate. This illuminates the ABS/ESP warning light on the dashboard, which is a reason for MOT failure.
• Engine Management System Faults: As mentioned, any fault within the engine management system that triggers the EML will cause a fail.
• Lighting/Ancillary System Faults: ECUs also control many lighting functions and other vehicle systems. A failure here that results in lights not working correctly or other critical systems being disabled could also lead to a fail.

MOT Test Categories for Failure

MOT failures are categorised into 'Dangerous', 'Major', and 'Minor' defects. A 'Dangerous' defect means the vehicle must not be driven until repaired. A 'Major' defect requires immediate repair but doesn't necessarily make the vehicle immediately dangerous to drive. A 'Minor' defect is noted but will not cause a fail, though it should be repaired soon.

A chipped windscreen in the driver's line of sight is typically classified as a 'Major' defect. An illuminated EML or ABS warning light due to an ECU fault is also usually a 'Major' or 'Dangerous' defect, depending on the system affected.

Pre-MOT Checks: What to Look For

Before taking your car for its MOT, it's wise to conduct a few checks yourself. This can help you identify potential failure points, including those related to chips:

• Windscreen: Carefully inspect the entire windscreen for any chips or cracks, especially in the driver's primary field of vision.
• Warning Lights: Turn on your ignition (without starting the engine) and check that all warning lights illuminate briefly and then go out. If any warning lights (like the EML, ABS, or Airbag light) remain illuminated, this indicates a fault and will likely cause an MOT fail.
• Tyres: Check for bulges, cuts, or tread depth below the legal limit (1.6mm).
• Lights: Ensure all lights (headlights, taillights, indicators, brake lights) are working correctly.
• Brakes: While difficult to test thoroughly at home, listen for unusual noises and ensure the brake pedal feels firm.

Table: Common 'Chip' Related Failures

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1: Will a tiny chip in my windscreen fail the MOT?

A1: It depends on its location and size. A very small chip (less than 10mm) outside the driver's direct line of sight is unlikely to cause a fail. However, anything in the driver's view or larger than specified sizes will likely result in a fail.

Q2: I had my car 'chipped' for more power. Will it fail the MOT?

A2: The 'chipping' itself doesn't cause a fail, but if it leads to increased emissions or causes the Engine Management Light to come on, then yes, it will fail the MOT. Ensure any tuning is done by a reputable specialist and that emissions remain within legal limits.

Q3: What if my car's computer (ECU) is faulty?

A3: If a faulty ECU causes a critical system (like engine management, brakes, or lighting) to malfunction, and this is indicated by a warning light on the dashboard or an actual system failure, it will likely cause an MOT fail.

Q4: Can rust on my car body cause an MOT failure?

A4: Yes, if rust has caused significant corrosion or compromised the structural integrity of the vehicle in critical areas (like the chassis, suspension mounting points, or body panels), it can lead to an MOT failure.

Conclusion

So, to directly answer the question: 'Can a chip fail an MOT?' Yes, but it depends entirely on what kind of 'chip' we're talking about. A physical chip on your windscreen in a critical area is a definite risk. Electronic 'chips' (ECUs) can cause a fail if they malfunction, leading to warning lights or system failures, or if software modifications result in excessive emissions. Always ensure your vehicle's safety systems and emission controls are functioning correctly, and get any windscreen damage assessed promptly to maximise your chances of passing the MOT test.

If you want to read more articles similar to MOT Failures: Can a Chip Cause an MOT Failure?, you can visit the MOT category.