Can a spare tyre fail a MOT?

Avoid MOT Tyre Fails: Your Ultimate Guide

14/10/2023

Rating: 4 (4456 votes)

Did you know that a staggering 11% of all MOT test fails in the UK are due to faulty tyres? According to the latest Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency (DVSA) figures, tyre failure stands as the third most common reason for MOT fails, trailing only behind faulty brakes, and lighting & signalling. This statistic alone underscores the critical importance of maintaining your vehicle's tyres, not just for passing the annual MOT, but more crucially, for your safety and the safety of others on the road. Understanding the common pitfalls and knowing how to perform regular checks can save you from an unexpected MOT failure, and potentially, a dangerous situation.

What is a Bald Tyre?
A bald tyre is when the tread has either worn down to below the legal minimum or worn away completely. A tyre’s ‘tread’ refers to the grooves along the outer surface which help you maintain grip on the road.
Table

The Silent Danger: Worn Tyre Treads and MOT Failure

Of the 11% of MOT failures attributed to faulty tyres, the overwhelming majority stem from illegal, worn-down tyre treads. These essential grooves in the rubber, first invented by Continental Tyres in 1904, play a vital role in channelling water away from the 'contact patch' where the tyre meets the road. Without adequate tread, this crucial water displacement cannot occur, leading to a severe loss of traction. Imagine trying to stop on a wet road with minimal grip – it's a perilous scenario. Grip is fundamental for safe braking, precise steering, and reliable acceleration. It's no wonder, then, that tyres are such a pivotal component of the MOT assessment.

If your tyre treads are excessively worn, they become inherently dangerous. This is precisely why the UK has established a legal minimum tyre tread depth of 1.6mm across the central three-quarters of the tread around the entire circumference of the tyre. Any measurement below this threshold renders your tyres illegal and, more importantly, severely compromises your vehicle's safety and handling capabilities, particularly in adverse weather conditions.

How to Best Avoid Tyre Tread Wear Fails

Regular inspection of your tyre treads is absolutely vital. You should be on the lookout for shallow treads, which often manifest as a shiny tyre surface. If you observe this on your tyres, it's a strong indicator that a new set might be imminent. To definitively confirm whether your treads meet the legal requirement, you can perform a simple '20p coin test'. Insert a 20p coin into the main grooves of your tyre tread at several points across the tyre's width and around its circumference. If, at any point, you can see the outer band of the coin (the part with the lettering), then your tyres are below the legal limit. In this scenario, it's not merely time to consider new tyres; it's time to act immediately. Driving on tyres with insufficient tread depth is not only illegal but also extremely dangerous, significantly increasing your stopping distances and the risk of hydroplaning.

Prolonging the Life of Your Tyres: Smart Maintenance

While all tyres will eventually wear down, proper maintenance can significantly extend their lifespan, ensuring they remain safe and legal for longer. This not only contributes to road safety but also offers financial benefits through improved fuel efficiency and delayed replacement costs.

Maintain the Right Tyre Pressures

One of the most impactful and yet often overlooked aspects of tyre maintenance is ensuring they are inflated to the correct pressure. Your vehicle manufacturer specifies the optimal tyre pressures, usually found on a sticker inside the driver's door jamb, in the glove compartment, or within the owner's manual. When tyres are inflated to the correct level, the load and wear are distributed evenly across the tread surface. This promotes uniform wear, meaning your tyres last longer. Conversely, under-inflated tyres will wear more heavily on the outer edges, while over-inflated tyres will wear excessively in the centre. Both scenarios lead to premature wear, reduced grip, and decreased fuel efficiency. Correctly inflated tyres not only enhance safety but also contribute to better fuel economy, as they minimise rolling resistance.

Don’t Waste Money on Part-Worn Tyres

While the allure of cheaper part-worn tyres can be strong, they often represent a false economy and a significant safety risk. UK Council Trading Standards teams across the country consistently report that part-worn tyres are frequently sold with questionable repairs, inaccurate labelling, and insufficient tread depth. Because they are second-hand, a significant portion of the tyre's original tread has already been worn away, meaning their safe usable life is considerably shorter than new tyres. Investing in new tyres, even if they cost more upfront, provides peace of mind, maximum tread depth, and a full lifespan, ultimately proving to be safer and more economical in the long run.

All Tyres Eventually Wear Down

Even with diligent maintenance and correct inflation, all tyres will gradually wear down over time. The key is to manage this process effectively, ensuring your tyres remain as safe as possible for their entire lifespan. It's worth noting that the quality of the tyre compound plays a significant role in its longevity. Premium tyres, such as those from leading manufacturers like Continental, often utilise superior compounds that are engineered to wear down slower and more evenly than cheaper tyres with inferior compounds. This extended durability, combined with enhanced performance characteristics, often justifies the higher initial investment.

The Integrity of Your Tyres: Sidewall Bulges and Cuts

The sidewall of your tyre is a critical component, essential for absorbing pressure, supporting the vehicle's weight, and maintaining car stability. Just like tyre treads, regular inspection of your tyre sidewalls is highly encouraged. If you notice a bulge in the sidewall, or any nicks, tears, or bubbles, it is almost always a sign of serious internal tyre damage. This damage can be a result of impacts, under-inflation, or manufacturing defects. For your driver safety – as well as that of other motorists – it is paramount that you get any such damage checked by an expert immediately. If an MOT inspector spots sidewall damage during your test, it will result in an immediate fail, without exception, as it represents a significant safety hazard that could lead to a sudden tyre blowout.

Avoiding Sidewall Damage – Five Top Tips

Preventing sidewall damage is crucial for tyre longevity and safety. Here are five practical tips:

  1. Avoid Scuffing Your Tyres Against Kerbs: A very typical cause of sidewall damage is repeatedly striking or scuffing your tyres against kerbs or pavements, particularly when parking. A rough impact can compromise the integrity of the tyre's internal structure, leading to weakened spots, bulges, or even immediate damage. Develop careful parking habits to avoid this common pitfall.
  2. Potholes – Avoid Them at All Costs: The UK's roads are unfortunately riddled with potholes, which can inflict serious damage on your tyres and suspension. Heavy thumps, bangs, and scrapes from encountering potholes can lead to internal damage that may not be immediately visible but can manifest as bulges or rapid air loss later. Be extra vigilant and avoid potholes whenever possible.
  3. Maintain the Right Tyre Pressures: Incorrect tyre pressure, whether under or over-inflation, places undue stress on the tyre's sidewall. When tyres are insufficiently filled with air, the sidewall is forced to flex more excessively, leading to premature fatigue and potential failure. Similarly, over-inflation can make the sidewall more rigid and susceptible to impact damage. Maintaining correct pressure ensures the sidewall functions as intended, distributing stress evenly.
  4. A Clean Tyre is Better Than a Dirty Tyre: While it might seem trivial, exposure to certain chemicals can degrade tyre compounds. If you've had the misfortune to spill petrol or other solvents on your tyres, or driven through really dirty, oily water, it's essential to clean off whatever's left on the tyres with water and washing-up liquid as soon as possible. Regular tyre inspection will help you to spot any exposure to solvents and oils. If left unattended, these chemicals can soften the tyre compounds, ultimately compromising the strength and integrity of the tyre sidewall.
  5. Keep a Sharp Lookout for Sharp Objects: MOT inspectors are meticulously on the lookout for tyre damage caused by debris, particularly sharp objects like nails, glass, or metal shards. The reason is clear: if cuts, tears, and nicks are left to linger within the tyre sidewall (or any other part of the tyre for that matter), they will, in all likelihood, result in lasting damage, such as punctures or sidewall failures. This can be best avoided through regular visual tyre inspections. The sooner you can spot and safely prise debris out of your tyre, the less chance it has of causing any lasting, catastrophic damage.

Faulty Tyre Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS)

Your Tyre Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS) is a relatively modern automotive technology designed to make identifying tyre pressure issues easier for motorists. It uses sensors embedded in or near the tyres to continuously measure their pressure and alert the driver if pressure drops significantly. However, like all technology, TPMS needs to be correctly maintained, and if neglected, it can fail. What many drivers aren't aware of is that these systems are also inspected as part of the MOT test. If your TPMS warning light is on, or if the system is found to be faulty, it will result in an MOT test failure. To avoid this, make sure you get your TPMS checked whenever you have your vehicle serviced, and especially whenever you change your tyres, as sensors can sometimes be damaged during fitting.

Can a damaged tyre sidewall cause an MOT failure?
Yes, a damaged tyre sidewall can cause an MOT failure if the damage is severe enough to compromise safety. The MOT test checks for cuts, bulges, or significant damage to the tyre sidewall.

Common Tyre Issues & MOT Implications

To provide a clearer overview, here's a summary of common tyre issues and their potential impact on your MOT test:

Tyre IssueDescriptionMOT ImplicationRecommended Action
Worn Tread DepthBelow legal minimum of 1.6mm across central 3/4 of tread.Major Defect / FailImmediate tyre replacement.
Sidewall Bulges/LumpsVisible swelling on the tyre sidewall, indicating internal damage.Major Defect / FailImmediate tyre replacement; do not drive.
Sidewall Cuts/TearsCuts exposing cords, or significant tears/nicks.Major Defect / FailImmediate tyre replacement.
Embedded ObjectsNails, screws, or other sharp objects embedded in the tread or sidewall.Minor/Major Defect (depends on severity/location)Inspect and remove if safe; professional repair/replacement if deep or on sidewall.
Incorrect Tyre PressureSignificantly over or under-inflated.Advisory / Minor DefectAdjust to correct pressure immediately.
TPMS Warning Light OnSystem malfunction or low pressure detected by TPMS.Major Defect / FailInvestigate and repair TPMS or inflate tyres correctly.
Tyre Cracking (Perishing)Small cracks in the rubber, often due to age or UV exposure.Minor/Major Defect (depends on severity)Monitor; consider replacement if cracks are deep or widespread.

Frequently Asked Questions About MOT Tyre Fails

Understanding the nuances of tyre maintenance and MOT requirements can be complex. Here are some common questions drivers often have:

What is the legal minimum tyre tread depth in the UK?

The legal minimum tyre tread depth in the UK is 1.6mm, measured across the central three-quarters of the tread width and around the entire circumference of the tyre. Driving with less than this is illegal and highly dangerous.

Can under-inflated tyres cause damage to my car?

Yes, under-inflated tyres can cause several issues. They lead to excessive flexing of the sidewalls, generating heat and causing premature wear, particularly on the outer edges of the tread. This can also compromise handling, increase braking distances, and significantly reduce fuel efficiency. Prolonged under-inflation can even lead to tyre failure, such as a blowout.

Are part-worn tyres a good way to save money?

While seemingly cheaper upfront, part-worn tyres are generally not recommended. They often have significantly reduced tread depth, questionable repair histories, and a much shorter lifespan compared to new tyres. They can be a false economy and, more importantly, pose significant safety risks due to their unknown past and reduced performance capabilities. It's always safer and often more cost-effective in the long run to invest in new, quality tyres.

How often should I check my tyre pressures?

It is recommended to check your tyre pressures at least once a month, and always before a long journey. You should check them when the tyres are cold, as driving heats them up and increases pressure, leading to an inaccurate reading. Refer to your vehicle's handbook or the sticker inside the door jamb for the correct pressures.

What should I do if I see a bulge on my tyre sidewall?

If you notice a bulge or lump on your tyre sidewall, it indicates serious internal damage to the tyre's structure. This is a critical safety issue and the tyre should be replaced immediately. Do not attempt to repair it, and avoid driving on it if possible. Seek professional advice without delay.

Does my TPMS need to be working for the MOT?

Yes, if your vehicle was manufactured on or after 1st January 2012, it is likely fitted with a TPMS. For these vehicles, a faulty or illuminated TPMS warning light will result in an MOT failure. Ensure your TPMS is functioning correctly by addressing any warning lights and having it checked during servicing.

Conclusion: Your Tyres, Your Safety

With regular visual checks and diligent maintenance, you can significantly minimise the chances of an MOT tyre fail. These routine inspections will not only help to prolong the life of your tyres, saving you money on premature replacements and even improving your fuel economy, but most importantly, they will help keep you and everyone around you safer on the roads. Tyres are your vehicle's only contact with the road, and their condition is paramount to safe driving.

If you're still unsure as to whether your tyres are damaged and risk failing an MOT, or if you simply need expert advice on tyre safety and solutions, do not hesitate to speak with a qualified professional. They can provide impartial tyre safety advice and recommend the best solutions for your vehicle, ensuring you drive away with confidence and peace of mind.

If you want to read more articles similar to Avoid MOT Tyre Fails: Your Ultimate Guide, you can visit the Maintenance category.

Go up