Nissan Elgrand E51: The Ultimate People Carrier?

When it comes to transporting a family or a group of friends in comfort and style, few vehicles can rival the presence and capability of a large MPV. For those in the market for something a little different, a step away from the mainstream European offerings, the Nissan Elgrand E51 presents a compelling proposition. This Japanese import, often referred to as a 'JDM' (Japanese Domestic Market) vehicle, has carved out a niche for itself amongst discerning buyers seeking luxury, space, and a touch of exclusivity. But is the Elgrand E51 the right choice for your needs? Let's delve into what makes this people carrier stand out, and importantly, what you should consider before taking the plunge.

The Appeal of the Elgrand E51: Luxury and Space

The Nissan Elgrand E51 is the second generation of Nissan's premium minivan, and it's this iteration that has garnered the most attention in the UK market. It’s a vehicle designed with passenger comfort and convenience at its core, offering a level of luxury that often surpasses its European contemporaries. The exterior styling, while subjective, is generally considered more dynamic and less boxy than many other MPVs, with a distinctive front grille and a commanding road presence. The E51 received a minor facelift towards the end of 2004, with earlier models featuring a horizontal body-coloured trim strip on the front grille, while later versions omit this detail.

Powertrain and Drivetrain Options

Under the bonnet, the Elgrand E51 typically boasts a potent 3.5-litre V6 engine, producing around 240 bhp. This is the same engine found in sporty vehicles like the Nissan 350Z, meaning the Elgrand offers more than enough grunt for effortless cruising and confident overtaking. For those seeking slightly more economy or perhaps a different driving characteristic, a 2.5-litre V6 engine with around 186 bhp was also available. Both engine options are paired with a smooth 5-speed automatic gearbox. A significant advantage of the Elgrand E51 is its availability with either rear-wheel drive or a switchable 4-wheel drive system. The 4WD system, complete with a centre differential lock, is particularly advantageous for those who frequently encounter adverse weather conditions, such as snow or ice, or for those who enjoy outdoor pursuits like camping and towing.

Interior Accommodation: The Star of the Show

The true magic of the Elgrand E51 lies within its cabin. Depending on the trim level and seat configuration, it can comfortably accommodate 7 or 8 passengers. The seating arrangement is highly flexible, with the middle row often featuring 'captain's chairs' rather than a bench. These seats can swivel to face the rear, creating a more social environment, and on higher trim levels, they even come with integrated retractable leg rests, offering a first-class travel experience. The third row seats are also well-appointed and can be folded away to the sides, significantly increasing boot space for luggage. While it's marketed as an 8-seater, realistically, the Elgrand E51 offers truly luxurious and spacious accommodation for six people, or four if you need maximum cargo capacity. The attention to detail in the interior is impressive, with high-quality materials and a sense of occasion that’s hard to match.

Equipment and Features: A Plethora of Luxuries

Nissan equipped the Elgrand E51 generously, even on its lower trim levels. Common features include:

• Exterior Enhancements: Front fog lights, HID/Xenon headlights, 16 or 17-inch alloy wheels, and power-folding mirrors.
• Driver Convenience: Power-assisted steering (PAS), electric windows (EW), electric mirrors (EM), central locking, and an adjustable steering column.
• Keyless Entry and Start: Many models feature Nissan's 'Smart Key' system, allowing keyless entry and engine start for ultimate convenience.
• Radar Cruise Control: A sophisticated system that maintains a set distance from the vehicle in front, reducing driver fatigue on long journeys.
• Safety Features: Multiple airbags, Anti-lock Braking System (ABS) with Electronic Brakeforce Distribution (EBD), and seatbelt pre-tensioners contribute to a safe driving experience.
• In-Car Entertainment: Higher-spec models often boast a Bose 9-speaker sound system, including a subwoofer for rich audio. A rear-mounted TV screen was also a popular option, though the TV function itself may not work in the UK due to differing broadcast standards; the DVD functionality remains.
• Comfort and Convenience: Leather upholstery, dual-zone climate control, power-adjustable front seats, and even twin sunroofs are not uncommon. The power rear doors, operable via the remote key and from the driver's seat, add a touch of effortless luxury.
• Interior Trim: Wood trim panels on the dashboard and doors enhance the premium feel, and some models even feature power-operated curtains for added privacy and light control.

Understanding the Trim Levels

Navigating the trim levels of Japanese imports can sometimes be a challenge, but here's a general hierarchy for the Elgrand E51:

• V: The entry-level trim, typically featuring cloth seats, often in a beige hue.
• VG: A slightly upgraded version of the V trim.
• Highway Star: A very popular mid-range option, often featuring half-leather seats and a sportier aesthetic.
• Rider S: An enhanced Rider model.
• Rider: Known for its distinctive styling enhancements, including extra chrome detailing on the grille, larger alloy wheels, and a body kit. Full leather seats are often available.
• X: A well-equipped trim level.
• XL: The most luxurious and expensive trim, generally offering the highest specification and often full leather seating, sometimes with a less ostentatious styling package than the Rider.

Potential Downsides to Consider

While the Elgrand E51 offers a great deal, it's crucial to be aware of its potential drawbacks:

• Fuel Consumption: With a kerb weight of 1.9 to 2.2 tonnes and a powerful 3.5-litre V6 engine, fuel economy is not its strong suit. Expecting around 20-25 mpg is realistic, depending heavily on driving style and conditions.
• Maintenance and Parts: As an imported vehicle, sourcing specific parts can sometimes be more challenging and potentially more expensive than for UK-market cars. However, specialist importers and online JDM parts suppliers are increasingly making this easier. For example, essential consumables like brake pads are readily available from specialist suppliers. A quick search for "Nissan Elgrand E51 brake pads" will reveal options, such as high-quality aftermarket sets from Japan, designed for quiet operation, high heat resistance, and low dust production. These are often made from non-asbestos organic material and are a reliable choice for maintaining your vehicle's braking system. Companies often stock these parts in locations like Vancouver, BC, making them accessible within Canada and internationally.
• Reliability: While Nissan's V6 engines are generally robust, the overall build quality and long-term durability, in my opinion, might not quite reach the benchmark set by Toyota's equivalent offerings, such as the Alphard. However, this is a subjective assessment, and many Elgrand owners report excellent reliability.

Which Elgrand E51 Should You Buy?

My recommendation leans towards the 3.5-litre V6 engine, especially when paired with the optional 4WD system. This combination provides the most effortless performance and the best all-weather capability. If you don't anticipate driving in challenging conditions, rear-wheel drive will suffice and might offer a slightly more engaging driving experience. For interior colours, I'd advise opting for a darker interior scheme. Light-coloured upholstery, while initially appearing luxurious, tends to show dirt and wear more readily and can look dated sooner than darker alternatives. The Highway Star trim, with its half-leather seats and sporty styling, offers a fantastic balance of luxury and value. If your budget allows, the Rider or XL trims provide an even more premium experience.

Alternatives to the Nissan Elgrand E51

If the Elgrand E51 doesn't quite tick all your boxes, or you're simply exploring the market, the most direct competitor is the Toyota Alphard. The Alphard is renowned for its exceptional build quality and refinement. Another option to consider is the Honda Elysion. If you're looking for something a little smaller and potentially more budget-friendly, consider models like the Toyota Noah/Voxy, Nissan Serena, or Honda Stepwagon.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: Is the Nissan Elgrand E51 a reliable car?
Nissan's V6 engines are generally robust. While overall long-term durability might slightly trail that of some Toyota rivals, many Elgrand owners report excellent reliability. Regular maintenance is key.

Q2: What is the fuel economy like on the Elgrand E51?
Due to its size, weight, and 3.5-litre V6 engine, expect fuel consumption in the region of 20-25 mpg, depending on driving conditions and style.

Q3: Can I get parts for the Nissan Elgrand E51 in the UK?
Yes, specialist JDM importers and online retailers offer a good range of parts, including common consumables like brake pads, filters, and even more significant components.

Q4: Is the 4WD system on the Elgrand E51 effective?
Yes, the switchable 4WD system with a centre differential lock provides significantly improved traction in slippery conditions, making it a valuable feature for winter driving or off-pavement use.

Q5: What are the main differences between trim levels?
Trim levels primarily differ in terms of interior materials (cloth vs. leather), exterior styling enhancements (body kits, chrome accents), and the inclusion of premium features like sunroofs, upgraded sound systems, and radar cruise control.

Conclusion

The Nissan Elgrand E51 remains a highly desirable large MPV for those who prioritise space, comfort, and a touch of luxury. Its powerful V6 engine, flexible interior, and often generous specification make it a standout choice. While fuel economy is a consideration, the overall package offers a unique and enjoyable ownership experience. If you're looking for a premium people carrier that stands out from the crowd, the Elgrand E51 is certainly worth serious consideration.