MOT Failure: Can a Faulty Rearview Mirror Fail?

When preparing your vehicle for its annual MOT test, it’s natural to focus on the big-ticket items like brakes, tyres, and lights. However, sometimes the seemingly minor components can surprisingly lead to a test failure. One such item often overlooked is the rearview mirror. So, can a faulty rearview mirror indeed cause your car to fail its MOT? The straightforward answer is yes, absolutely. Mirrors are not just a convenience; they are crucial safety devices, and their condition and functionality are thoroughly checked during the MOT.

The MOT test is designed to ensure that vehicles on UK roads meet minimum safety and environmental standards. Mirrors play a vital role in a driver's ability to safely navigate traffic, change lanes, and reverse, providing a comprehensive view of the surrounding environment. Without properly functioning mirrors, blind spots become dangerous liabilities, significantly increasing the risk of accidents. Consequently, the Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency (DVSA) has clear guidelines regarding the condition and presence of mirrors, and any significant deviation from these standards will result in a failed test.

The MOT Requirements for Vehicle Mirrors

The MOT test manual, which inspectors strictly adhere to, outlines precise criteria for mirrors. The requirements vary slightly depending on the age of your vehicle, specifically whether it was first used before or after 1st August 1978. For most modern vehicles (those first used on or after 1st August 1978), the rules are more stringent, reflecting advancements in vehicle design and safety standards.

Generally, vehicles must be equipped with a sufficient number of mirrors to provide an adequate view to the rear and side. For cars, this typically means:

• An interior rearview mirror (unless it's impossible to fit one, or it doesn't provide a clear view to the rear, such as in a panel van or certain commercial vehicles).
• An offside (driver's side) exterior mirror.
• A nearside (passenger's side) exterior mirror (often required for vehicles first used on or after 1st January 1986).

The key here is 'adequate view'. Each mirror must be securely fitted, not excessively damaged, and capable of providing a clear, undistorted view of the road behind and to the sides. If an inspector deems that any of these conditions are not met, your vehicle is at risk of failing the MOT.

Common Mirror Faults That Lead to MOT Failure

Understanding the specific types of mirror faults that can cause an MOT failure is crucial for pre-test checks. Here are the most common issues:

Missing Mirrors

Perhaps the most obvious reason for a mirror-related failure is a missing mirror. If your vehicle is required to have a specific mirror (e.g., the offside exterior mirror) and it's completely absent, this will result in a major defect and an automatic MOT failure. This includes cases where a mirror has been knocked off and not replaced.

Severely Cracked or Shattered Glass

While a tiny chip or a minor crack at the very edge of a mirror might sometimes get an advisory rather than a fail, any significant damage to the mirror glass that obscures the driver's view will lead to a failure. If the crack spiderwebs across the mirror, distorts the reflection, or is large enough to impair the ability to see clearly behind or to the side, it's a fail. Inspectors will assess whether the damage compromises the mirror's primary function of providing an adequate view. Furthermore, if the glass is shattered and presents a safety hazard (e.g., sharp edges), this can also be a reason for failure.

Loose or Insecurely Mounted Mirrors

A mirror must be securely fixed to the vehicle. If an interior or exterior mirror is loose, wobbly, or cannot be held in a fixed position to provide a constant, clear view, it will fail the MOT. This is because a loose mirror cannot reliably perform its function, as its angle will shift with vehicle movement, bumps, or wind, rendering it ineffective for safe driving.

Obscured View

Anything that permanently obscures the view provided by a mirror can also lead to a failure. This could include stickers, excessive tinting, or even persistent dirt that cannot be easily cleaned. The mirror's reflective surface must be clear and unobstructed.

Malfunctioning Adjustment Mechanisms

While not always an automatic failure if the mirror can still be manually positioned, if an electrically adjustable mirror cannot be moved to provide an adequate view, or if its heating element (if fitted) is essential for maintaining a clear view in certain conditions and is not working, it could lead to an advisory or, in some cases, a failure. The primary concern is always the ability to get a clear and stable view.

Why Mirrors Are Absolutely Crucial for Road Safety

The stringent MOT requirements for mirrors underscore their fundamental role in road safety. Mirrors are your eyes on the road behind and to the sides, enabling you to:

• Check Blind Spots: Even with modern blind spot monitoring systems, physical mirror checks are essential to confirm that no other vehicle, cyclist, or pedestrian is in your blind spot before changing lanes or turning.
• Perform Manoeuvres Safely: Reversing, parking, and pulling out from a curb all rely heavily on accurate mirror use to avoid collisions.
• Monitor Traffic Flow: Keeping an eye on what's happening behind you allows for proactive driving, such as adjusting your speed if you see an emergency vehicle approaching or a fast-moving vehicle behind you.
• React to Hazards: A clear view to the rear and sides allows you to identify potential hazards early and take evasive action if necessary.

Without functional mirrors, a driver's field of vision is severely limited, making even routine driving tasks significantly more dangerous. This is why the MOT test places such importance on them.

Pre-MOT Checks for Your Mirrors

Before you take your car in for its MOT, it's highly advisable to perform a quick check of all your mirrors. This simple five-minute inspection could save you the inconvenience and cost of a retest. Here’s what to look for:

• Presence: Are all the mirrors your vehicle is supposed to have actually there?
• Security: Gently push and pull on each mirror. Does it feel firmly attached to the vehicle, or does it wobble excessively? It should not move freely.
• Condition of Glass: Inspect the mirror glass for any cracks, chips, or discolouration. Is the damage significant enough to obstruct your view? Remember, a crack that makes the mirror unusable for its intended purpose is a definite fail.
• Cleanliness: Ensure the mirror surfaces are clean and free from dirt, grime, or stickers that could obscure the view. While dirt isn't a direct MOT fail, a dirty mirror prevents the inspector from properly assessing its condition.
• Adjustability: If your mirrors are adjustable (manual or electric), check that they can be moved to the correct position and, crucially, that they stay in that position without drifting.

If you identify any issues during your pre-MOT check, it’s best to get them repaired or replaced before the test. This proactive approach ensures your vehicle is in the best possible condition for inspection.

Advisory vs. Failure: What’s the Difference?

It's important to distinguish between an 'advisory' and a 'failure' when it comes to the MOT. An advisory note indicates a defect that is not severe enough to fail the test but should be monitored or repaired in the near future. A failure means the defect is significant enough that the vehicle is deemed unroadworthy and cannot be driven on public roads until the issue is rectified and a retest is passed.

For mirrors, minor cosmetic blemishes or very small chips outside the critical viewing area might result in an advisory. However, anything that compromises the mirror's ability to provide a clear and adequate view, or its secure fitting, will almost certainly lead to a failure. The inspector's discretion plays a role, but they operate within strict guidelines.

Mirror Faults and Their MOT Outcome

To help clarify, here's a comparison of common mirror faults and their likely MOT outcome:

Frequently Asked Questions About Mirrors and the MOT

Do I need all three mirrors (interior, driver's side, passenger's side) for the MOT?

For most modern cars (first used after 1st January 1986), you will need an interior mirror (if it provides a clear view to the rear) and both an offside (driver's) and nearside (passenger's) exterior mirror. Vehicles first used between 1st August 1978 and 1st January 1986 require at least two mirrors, one of which must be the offside exterior. Older vehicles (pre-1st August 1978) only need one mirror providing an adequate view to the rear.

What if my rearview mirror is just chipped, not fully cracked?

If the chip is small, at the edge, and does not significantly obscure your view, it might result in an advisory. However, if the chip is large, in your direct line of sight, or compromises the mirror's integrity, it could lead to a fail. It's always safer to replace it.

Can I fix a cracked mirror myself with tape or adhesive?

No, temporary fixes like tape or adhesive are unlikely to pass the MOT. The repair must be durable and not obscure the view. If the mirror glass is cracked, it needs to be replaced properly. A DIY repair might even make the situation worse if it adds to the obstruction or creates a sharp edge.

My electric mirror adjustment isn't working, but I can still move it by hand. Will it fail?

Typically, if the mirror can still be manually adjusted and held in a fixed position to provide an adequate view, a non-functioning electric adjustment mechanism will likely result in an advisory rather than a fail. However, if the electric fault prevents you from positioning the mirror correctly at all, it would be a fail.

Are aftermarket mirrors acceptable for the MOT?

Yes, aftermarket mirrors are generally acceptable as long as they meet the MOT requirements for size, security, and provide an adequate, clear, and undistorted view to the rear. They must be designed for automotive use and securely fitted.

What if my interior mirror is missing because I have a panel van and it's useless?

For vehicles where an interior mirror cannot provide a clear view to the rear (e.g., panel vans, some commercial vehicles, or vehicles with permanent rear obstructions), it is not a requirement to have one, provided the vehicle has the necessary exterior mirrors (offside and nearside) to give an adequate view to the rear.

Conclusion

In summary, a faulty rearview mirror can indeed cause your car to fail its MOT. Mirrors are integral safety features, and their condition is not taken lightly by MOT inspectors. Whether it's a completely missing mirror, a severely cracked or shattered glass, or a mirror that simply won't stay in position, any defect that compromises your ability to see clearly behind and to the sides of your vehicle will result in a failed test. Performing simple, routine checks on your mirrors before your MOT appointment is a small effort that can save you significant hassle, time, and money. Ensuring your mirrors are in good working order isn't just about passing the MOT; it's about ensuring your safety and the safety of others on the road.

If you want to read more articles similar to MOT Failure: Can a Faulty Rearview Mirror Fail?, you can visit the MOT category.