Can rear view camera cause MOT failure?

Rear View Camera & MOT: Will Yours Pass?

23/06/2009

Rating: 4.67 (6771 votes)

Rear view cameras have become an invaluable aid for drivers across the UK, significantly enhancing safety and convenience, especially when parking or reversing in tight spots. From factory-fitted systems to a plethora of aftermarket options, these technological additions are now commonplace. However, with any modification or addition to your vehicle, a crucial question arises: "Will it affect my MOT?" Specifically, when it comes to rear view camera screens, there are indeed circumstances under which they could lead to an MOT failure, primarily revolving around their placement and impact on driver visibility. Understanding these specific regulations is paramount for any vehicle owner looking to ensure their car remains roadworthy and compliant.

Does a dashcam pass a MOT?
Both the entire camera and the entire mount are in the swept area, yet it passed an MOT just fine. The 4th image in my post shows this clearly as the windscreen is wet and the swept area is quite visible. If it definitely only obscures your view of the sky, then you're obstruction (the dashcam) is exempt and should pass an MOT.
Table

The Critical Rule: Windscreen Obstruction and the Swept Area

The core principle governing whether your rear view camera screen could cause an MOT failure is straightforward yet critically important: its placement must not impede your line of sight through the windscreen, particularly within the area cleared by your wipers. The MOT test is fundamentally about ensuring your vehicle meets essential safety and environmental standards, and an unobstructed view of the road ahead is a non-negotiable safety requirement.

The swept area of the windscreen refers to the section that the windscreen wipers are designed to keep clear. This is the primary field of vision for the driver, and any significant obstruction within this zone is treated very seriously. The logic is simple: if something blocks your view where you need to see most clearly, it compromises your ability to drive safely, react to hazards, and maintain full awareness of your surroundings.

When an MOT tester inspects your vehicle, they will assess whether the camera screen, regardless of whether it’s permanently on or only activates when reverse gear is engaged, creates an obstruction in this critical swept area. It's not just about the screen being there; it's about whether its presence genuinely impairs your vision. A small, thin wire might be negligible, but a substantial screen could certainly be deemed an issue. This assessment often involves a degree of discretion on the part of the tester, making correct placement even more crucial for owners.

Why Visibility Matters: Beyond Just the MOT

While the immediate concern might be passing the MOT, the underlying reason for these regulations is driver and road user safety. An impaired view can have severe consequences:

  • Reduced Hazard Perception: You might miss pedestrians, cyclists, other vehicles, or road signs.
  • Delayed Reaction Times: If you spot a hazard later, you have less time to react, increasing the risk of an accident.
  • Legal Implications: Driving with an obstructed view can also lead to fines or points on your licence, even outside of an MOT context, as it breaches construction and use regulations.

Therefore, positioning your rear view camera screen correctly isn't just about ticking a box for the MOT; it's about making a conscious decision to prioritise safety every time you get behind the wheel. The tester’s role is to identify potential safety compromises, and visibility is at the top of that list.

Understanding "Obstruction": What Do Testers Look For?

The term "obstruction" can sometimes feel subjective, but MOT testers follow guidelines to ensure consistency. They are looking for anything that significantly reduces the driver's effective field of vision.

  • Size and Location: A screen positioned directly in the driver's primary line of sight, especially if it's large, is a definite red flag. Even if it's small, if it's centrally placed and unavoidable, it could be an issue.
  • Permanent vs. Temporary: While the rule applies even if the screen only operates in reverse, a permanently illuminated screen in the swept area poses a greater continuous distraction and visibility issue.
  • Mounting Method: How the screen is mounted also plays a role. Is it securely attached? Are wires dangling in a way that could further obstruct or distract? While not directly about the screen itself, poor installation can compound visibility issues.

It's important to differentiate between minor items like a small sat-nav or phone holder that can be easily moved or positioned outside the critical area, and a fixed camera screen that permanently impacts your view. The latter is far more likely to attract scrutiny during an MOT.

Best Practices for Installation to Ensure MOT Compliance

Avoiding an MOT failure due to your rear view camera screen is largely within your control, provided you adhere to sensible installation practices.

  • Outside the Swept Area: This is the golden rule. Ideally, mount the screen where it does not encroach upon the area cleared by your wipers. This often means placing it low down on the dashboard, near the centre console, or integrated into an existing infotainment system screen.
  • Integrated Solutions: Many modern vehicles come with infotainment screens that can display the rear view camera feed. These are almost always positioned safely and are designed not to obstruct the primary view. If you have this option, it's generally the safest bet.
  • Windscreen-Mounted Screens: If you must mount on the windscreen, ensure it is either:
    • Completely outside the swept area.
    • In a very low position, ideally at the very bottom edge of the windscreen, where it minimally impacts forward vision.

    Avoid placing it high up, near the rearview mirror, unless it's designed to replace the mirror itself and is still compliant with visibility regulations.

  • Secure Mounting and Cable Management: Ensure the screen is firmly attached and does not wobble or obstruct the view due to loose mounting. Tidy away all cables. Loose cables can be a distraction, get tangled, or even block controls, indirectly affecting safety.
  • Consider Screen Size: A smaller screen is inherently less likely to cause an obstruction than a large one. Choose a screen size appropriate for its intended use and placement.

What About Other Dash-Mounted Devices?

The principles applied to rear view camera screens also extend to other devices you might have mounted on your dashboard or windscreen, such as dash cams, satellite navigation systems, or mobile phone holders. The overarching rule is consistent: if it obstructs your view through the windscreen's swept area, it could be an MOT concern.

It's often easier to reposition a dash cam or sat-nav for the MOT, but a permanently wired-in rear view camera screen requires more thoughtful initial placement. Remember, the MOT tester is looking at the vehicle as it is presented for the test.

Common Misconceptions and Clarifications

There are often misunderstandings about what specifically constitutes a failure point for rear view cameras.

  • The Camera Itself: The physical camera mounted at the rear of the vehicle is highly unlikely to cause an MOT failure unless it's dangerously loose or has sharp edges. The concern is almost exclusively with the display screen and its placement.
  • Functionality: The MOT test does not typically check the functionality of the rear view camera system itself (i.e., whether the image is clear, if it activates correctly). Their focus is on the physical obstruction.
  • Aftermarket vs. Factory-Fitted: The rules apply equally. A factory-fitted camera screen is designed to comply, but an aftermarket one must also meet the same visibility standards.

What to Do If You're Concerned

If you have a rear view camera screen and are unsure whether it might cause an MOT issue, here are some proactive steps:

  • Inspect It Yourself: Sit in the driver's seat and assess your field of vision, particularly through the swept area of the windscreen. Can you easily see all essential areas of the road ahead without straining or moving your head excessively?
  • Reposition if Necessary: If you identify a potential issue, try to reposition the screen. Many aftermarket screens are designed to be easily moved.
  • Consult a Professional: If you're still unsure, a reputable garage or MOT test centre can offer advice before your official test. They might be able to suggest optimal placement or even assist with professional installation.
  • Consider Removal for the Test: While not ideal for long-term use, if you have a non-permanent screen that you suspect will fail, you may remove it for the MOT test and then reinstall it afterwards in a compliant location. However, it is always best to have it properly installed for continuous safe driving.

Comparative Table: Screen Types and MOT Impact

Screen Type/LocationDescriptionPotential MOT ImpactRecommendation for MOT Compliance
Integrated Infotainment ScreenUses the vehicle's existing central display for camera feed.Very Low. These are designed by manufacturers to be compliant.Generally no action needed.
Dashboard-Mounted Screen (Low)Standalone screen placed low on the dash, below the swept area.Low. Minimal impact on primary vision.Ensure secure mounting and tidy wiring.
Windscreen-Mounted Screen (Low Edge)Standalone screen mounted at the very bottom edge of the windscreen.Medium. Can be borderline if it encroaches too much.Ensure it's truly at the absolute bottom and doesn't impede critical view.
Rear View Mirror Replacement ScreenScreen built into or clipped over the existing rear view mirror.Low. This area is generally not considered part of the primary forward swept area for obstruction.Ensure it doesn't create excessive glare or distraction.
Windscreen-Mounted Screen (Mid/High)Standalone screen mounted in the middle or upper part of the windscreen, within the swept area.High. This is the most common cause of failure.Reposition immediately. This is a significant obstruction risk.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Does the camera itself cause an MOT failure?

No, the physical rear view camera mounted at the back of your car does not typically cause an MOT failure. The concern is almost exclusively with the screen used to display the camera's feed, specifically if its placement obstructs the driver's view through the windscreen's swept area.

What if my screen only comes on when I'm in reverse?

The functionality of the screen (whether it's on permanently or only when reversing) does not change the MOT rule regarding obstruction. If the screen is physically present in the swept area of the windscreen, it still constitutes an obstruction, regardless of whether it's displaying an image or is blank. The potential for failure remains.

Can I just remove the screen for the MOT test?

Yes, if your rear view camera screen is easily removable and you suspect it might cause an MOT failure due to its placement, you can remove it for the test. However, it's always best practice to have all vehicle accessories installed in a compliant manner for everyday driving, prioritising safety over temporary fixes.

Are there specific dimensions for what counts as 'swept area'?

While the MOT test manual provides diagrams and guidelines, it doesn't give precise, universal dimensions that apply to every car. The 'swept area' is generally understood as the region of the windscreen that the wipers clear, which is critical for the driver's forward visibility. The tester will use their professional judgment based on these guidelines to determine if an item significantly obstructs this area.

Do aftermarket cameras have different rules than factory-fitted ones?

No, the rules for visibility and obstruction apply equally to both factory-fitted and aftermarket rear view camera systems. While factory-fitted systems are typically designed to be compliant, it's the responsibility of the vehicle owner to ensure any aftermarket installation also meets the required safety standards.

Does a dash cam also fall under these rules?

Yes, absolutely. Any device, including a dash cam, satellite navigation unit, or mobile phone holder, that is mounted on the windscreen or dashboard must not obstruct the driver's view through the swept area of the windscreen. The same principles of safe placement apply.

What if my screen causes glare or is a distraction?

While glare or distraction from a screen can be a significant driving hazard, the MOT test primarily focuses on physical obstruction of the driver's view. An MOT failure directly due to glare is less common than one due to a physical obstruction in the swept area. However, severe glare or distraction could be noted as an advisory or, in extreme cases, contribute to a dangerous defect assessment.

In conclusion, while rear view cameras are incredibly beneficial additions to any vehicle, their installation requires careful consideration, particularly concerning the placement of the display screen. The key takeaway for UK drivers is clear: if your rear view camera screen obstructs your view through the swept area of your windscreen, it may lead to an MOT failure. Prioritising safe and compliant placement not only helps you pass your annual MOT but, more importantly, ensures your continued safety and the safety of others on the road. Always aim for a setup that provides maximum visibility and minimises any potential distractions.

If you want to read more articles similar to Rear View Camera & MOT: Will Yours Pass?, you can visit the MOT category.

Go up