Does rust cause a 'fail'?

Rust and Your MOT: What You Need To Know

18/11/2020

Rating: 3.96 (8620 votes)

When it comes to vehicle safety and roadworthiness in the UK, the MOT test is paramount. Many car owners rightly fret over various potential issues that could lead to a failure, and rust is undoubtedly high on that list. However, there's often a misconception about how rust is actually assessed during an MOT. The test itself, of course, doesn't 'rust'; rather, your vehicle is meticulously inspected for any signs of corrosion that could compromise its structural integrity or safety. The key isn't just the presence of rust, but its location, type, and severity. Understanding these nuances is crucial for any car owner hoping to pass their annual inspection with flying colours.

Will a rear sill fail if the second layer is solid?
As the outer rear sill is actually the rear wing it shouldn't fail if the second layer is solid. But TBH it tends to depend upon the tester. corrosion within 30cm of a suspension/brake/steering or in your case seat belt mounting is a fail.... Bummer.

Rust, or corrosion, is a natural enemy of metal, and given the UK's often damp climate, it's a constant battle for our vehicles. While a bit of surface rust on non-structural components might be an aesthetic concern, penetrating or structural rust can pose a significant safety risk. The MOT test is designed precisely to identify these risks, ensuring that your car is safe for you, your passengers, and other road users. So, let's delve into what an MOT inspector looks for when it comes to rust and how you can prepare your vehicle.

Table

The MOT Test: A Comprehensive Rust Check

During an MOT, the inspector will thoroughly examine your vehicle for signs of corrosion, paying particular attention to areas that are critical for its structural integrity and safe operation. It's not just about visible rust; they're looking for anything that might weaken the vehicle's chassis, suspension mounting points, braking system components, or steering. The assessment isn't based on a simple measurement like '30cm of rust' but rather on the *impact* of the corrosion on the vehicle's safety and structural soundness.

Where Do Inspectors Look for Rust?

MOT inspectors follow strict guidelines, focusing on areas where rust can be most dangerous. These include:

  • Vehicle Structure and Chassis: This is perhaps the most critical area. Significant corrosion in load-bearing areas, such as the sills, chassis rails, subframes, and body mounts, can severely compromise the vehicle's structural integrity. If these areas are weakened, the car's ability to withstand impacts or even normal driving stresses is reduced.
  • Suspension Mounting Points: Rust around where suspension components attach to the body or chassis is a major concern. If these points are corroded, the suspension could fail, leading to a loss of control.
  • Brake Pipes and Hoses: Corrosion on metal brake pipes can lead to leaks and brake failure. While surface rust is common, penetrating rust that compromises the pipe's integrity will result in a failure.
  • Steering Components: Any corrosion affecting steering linkages, steering racks, or their mounting points can lead to imprecise steering or, worse, a complete loss of steering control.
  • Seatbelt Anchorage Points: The points where seatbelts are bolted to the vehicle's structure must be absolutely solid. Rust here is a serious safety concern as it could prevent seatbelts from performing their life-saving function in a collision.
  • Bodywork (in relation to safety): While cosmetic rust on the body panels usually won't fail an MOT, sharp edges or perforations caused by rust that could injure a pedestrian or cyclist will.

Understanding Rust Classifications in the MOT

The MOT categorises defects, including rust, into Minor, Major, and Dangerous. The outcome of your test depends heavily on which category the corrosion falls into:

  • Minor Defects: These are issues that require attention but don't significantly affect the vehicle's safety or impact on the environment. For rust, this might be light surface corrosion on a non-structural component that doesn't compromise its function. While noted, it typically won't lead to an immediate failure, but it's an advisory to get it fixed.
  • Major Defects: These are issues that could affect the vehicle's safety, impact on the environment, or other road users. Significant corrosion in a structural area, or on a safety-critical component, that compromises its function would fall into this category. A major defect will result in an MOT failure.
  • Dangerous Defects: These defects pose a direct and immediate risk to road safety or have a serious impact on the environment. If rust has severely compromised a critical structural component, leading to a high risk of failure or collapse, it will be classified as dangerous. If your vehicle fails with a dangerous defect, it cannot be driven on the road until the issue is rectified.

When Does Rust Become a Failure?

The MOT manual specifies that corrosion becomes an issue when it significantly weakens a prescribed area or a safety-critical component. It's not about the exact size of a rust patch, but rather its *depth* and *location*. For instance, a small hole caused by penetrating rust in a chassis rail is far more serious than a large patch of surface rust on a non-structural door panel.

Key considerations for failure include:

  • Perforation: If the rust has eaten all the way through the metal, creating a hole. The size of the hole matters, but even small perforations in critical areas can be a failure.
  • Weakening: Even without full perforation, if the metal is severely thinned or weakened by corrosion to the point where it can no longer perform its function safely, it will fail. This is often tested by the inspector using a hammer to tap or prod the area.
  • Impact on Safety Systems: As mentioned, rust on brake pipes, steering components, or seatbelt anchors is a direct safety concern and will almost certainly lead to a failure.

The '30cm' Implication: Misconception vs. Reality

The query mentioning '30cm' likely stems from a general awareness that large areas of rust are problematic. While there isn't a specific '30cm rule' that applies universally to all rust in an MOT, the spirit of the concern is valid. Extensive corrosion, particularly in structural areas, *will* be a major concern. For example, if a significant section (which could easily be 30cm or more) of a sill or chassis rail is severely corroded, it will undoubtedly lead to a failure because it indicates a fundamental weakening of the vehicle's structure. The focus is on the *integrity* of the component, not merely its dimensions.

Preventing Rust: Your Best Defence

Prevention is always better than cure, especially when it comes to rust. Here are some tips to keep your vehicle corrosion-free:

  • Regular Washing: Especially in winter, wash your car regularly to remove salt, dirt, and other corrosive substances. Pay attention to the undercarriage.
  • Waxing and Polishing: A good coat of wax provides a protective barrier against moisture and contaminants.
  • Rust Proofing: Consider professional rust-proofing treatments, especially for older vehicles or if you live in an area prone to harsh weather. Underseal can protect the chassis and underbody components.
  • Address Scratches and Chips Promptly: Even small paint chips can expose bare metal to the elements, leading to rust. Touch them up as soon as you notice them.
  • Check Drainage Holes: Ensure that drainage holes in doors, sills, and boot lids are clear. Blocked holes can trap water, leading to internal corrosion.
  • Inspect Regularly: Get into the habit of checking your vehicle's underside and common rust spots yourself. Catching rust early can save you significant repair costs down the line.
Rust Type/LocationTypical MOT OutcomeExplanation
Surface rust on non-structural body panelAdvisory (Minor)Cosmetic issue, not affecting safety or structure.
Light surface rust on brake pipeAdvisory (Minor)Not yet compromising integrity, but needs monitoring.
Perforated rust in sill (small area)Major Defect (Failure)Compromises structural integrity, even if small.
Severe rust on suspension mounting pointMajor/Dangerous Defect (Failure)Direct safety risk, potential for component detachment.
Rust weakening chassis railMajor/Dangerous Defect (Failure)Fundamental structural weakness, high risk of collapse.
Corroded seatbelt anchorage pointDangerous Defect (Failure)Life-threatening safety risk, immediate repair needed.

Frequently Asked Questions About Rust and MOTs

Q: Can surface rust cause an MOT failure?
A: Generally, no. Surface rust that doesn't compromise the integrity of a structural or safety-critical component is usually an advisory. However, if it causes sharp edges that could injure someone, it could lead to a failure.

Q: How do MOT inspectors check for rust?
A: Inspectors conduct a visual inspection, often using a torch to look into hidden areas. They may also gently tap or prod suspicious areas with a small hammer to check for weak spots or hidden perforations.

Q: What are the most common areas for MOT rust failures?
A: Sills, chassis rails, subframes, suspension mounting points, brake pipes, and seatbelt anchorage points are very common areas for rust-related MOT failures.

Q: My car has rust under the bonnet. Will it fail?
A: It depends on the location and severity. Rust on non-structural components like battery trays or inner wings might be an advisory. However, if it affects structural components, suspension towers, or brake/steering lines in the engine bay, it will fail.

Q: Is it worth repairing rust for an MOT, or should I just get a new car?
A: This depends entirely on the extent and location of the rust. Minor rust repairs can be cost-effective. However, if the corrosion is extensive and in multiple structural areas, the cost of repairs might exceed the vehicle's value, making a new car a more sensible option.

Q: Can I repair rust myself before an MOT?
A: For minor, non-structural rust, you might be able to clean, treat, and paint it yourself. However, for structural rust or corrosion on safety-critical components, it's highly recommended to have a professional repair done. These repairs often require welding and specific structural integrity knowledge to ensure safety and compliance with MOT standards.

Q: What happens if my car fails the MOT due to rust?
A: If your car fails due to rust, you will receive a 'Refusal of an MOT Test Certificate' with details of the defects. You must get the rust professionally repaired (or repair it yourself if competent) and then have a retest. If the defect is classified as 'dangerous', you cannot drive the vehicle until it's repaired.

In conclusion, while the phrase '30cm MOT test rust' might be a misnomer, the concern about rust and its impact on your MOT is very real. The key takeaway is that the MOT test assesses the *safety and structural integrity* of your vehicle. Any rust that compromises these aspects, regardless of its exact size, will lead to a failure. Regular inspection, proactive maintenance, and prompt professional repair of any significant corrosion are your best strategies for keeping your vehicle roadworthy and passing your MOT with confidence.

If you want to read more articles similar to Rust and Your MOT: What You Need To Know, you can visit the Maintenance category.

Go up