Is this Porsche 911 (997) Carrera S a good car?

Porsche 911 (997) Carrera S: A Modern Classic

09/12/2018

Rating: 4.11 (16138 votes)

The Porsche 911 is a name synonymous with automotive excellence, performance, and enduring desirability. For many enthusiasts, the 997 generation of the 911, produced from 2004 to 2012, represents a sweet spot in the model's evolution, blending modern technology with a more analogue driving experience than its successors. Within this highly regarded generation, the Carrera S variant stands out as a particularly compelling proposition, offering a significant step up in performance and refinement over the standard Carrera. This article delves into what makes the Porsche 911 (997) Carrera S a truly exceptional car, exploring its history, technical prowess, driving dynamics, and why a well-maintained example, like the one described, is an excellent choice for discerning drivers.

When did the 911 Carrera 4S come out?
Table

The Evolution of the 911: Introducing the 997 Generation

The 997 generation marked a significant evolution for the iconic Porsche 911. Launched in 2004, it addressed some of the criticisms levelled at its predecessor, the 996, particularly in terms of styling and interior quality. Porsche designers returned to more classic 911 cues, with the distinctive round headlights making a welcome comeback. The interior also received a substantial upgrade, featuring higher-quality materials and a more cohesive design. Underneath the skin, the 997 boasted a revised chassis, improved suspension, and more powerful engines, all contributing to an even sharper and more engaging driving experience. The Carrera S model, introduced shortly after the initial Carrera launch, was specifically engineered to provide a more potent and dynamic package.

The Carrera S: More Power, More Precision

The 'S' in Carrera S signifies 'Sport' or 'Special', and in the context of the 997, it translates directly to enhanced performance. The 997 Carrera S models were equipped with larger displacement engines compared to their standard Carrera counterparts. Initially, the 997.1 Carrera S featured a 3.8-litre flat-six engine, producing a healthy 355 horsepower and 390 Nm of torque. This was a notable increase over the 3.6-litre engine in the standard Carrera. Later, the 997.2 generation, launched in 2008, saw further improvements. The 997.2 Carrera S also used a 3.8-litre engine, but it was an updated unit with direct fuel injection (DFI), boosting power to 385 horsepower and 420 Nm of torque. This DFI technology not only increased power but also improved fuel efficiency and reduced emissions.

Beyond the engine, the Carrera S models typically came with a range of performance-oriented features as standard or as readily available options. These often included larger brakes for superior stopping power, a limited-slip differential for improved traction and cornering ability, and suspension enhancements for sharper handling. The availability of Porsche's Active Suspension Management (PASM) system, which electronically adjusts damping force, further refined the ride and handling balance, allowing drivers to tailor the car's behaviour to their preferences and driving conditions. The transmission options were also a key differentiator, with both a precise six-speed manual gearbox and the highly acclaimed (and often preferred by purists) Porsche Doppelkupplung (PDK) automatic transmission available.

Driving Dynamics: The Heart of the 911 Experience

The 911's reputation is built on its exceptional driving dynamics, and the 997 Carrera S is no exception. The rear-engined layout, a hallmark of the 911 since its inception, provides a unique weight distribution that, when expertly managed by Porsche's engineers, results in incredible traction out of corners and a distinctive, engaging feel. The steering is renowned for its directness and feedback, allowing the driver to feel precisely what the front wheels are doing, a quality that has become increasingly rare in modern cars.

The 997 Carrera S, with its more potent engine and enhanced chassis, offers a truly exhilarating driving experience. Acceleration is strong and progressive, with the flat-six engine delivering a sonorous and characterful soundtrack. The car handles with remarkable agility and composure, sticking tenaciously to the road even at high speeds. The balance of the chassis is superb, making it incredibly confidence-inspiring for spirited driving on twisty roads or track days. The ability to select between 'Normal' and 'Sport' modes via the PASM system further allows for an adaptable driving experience, softening the ride for comfortable cruising or firming up the suspension for maximum performance.

Practicality Meets Performance: A Sports Car for All Occasions

One of the enduring appeals of the 911, and particularly the Carrera S, is its remarkable blend of supercar performance with everyday usability. Unlike many dedicated sports cars, the 911 offers a degree of practicality that makes it suitable for regular use. The cabin is well-appointed and comfortable, with supportive seats and a driver-focused dashboard. While the rear seats are small, they are sufficient for occasional use or for carrying small children. The front luggage compartment (frunk) provides a decent amount of space for weekend trips or shopping, adding to the car's versatility.

The specific example mentioned, with a rebuilt flat-six engine and excellent condition for its age, highlights the importance of maintenance and care in owning a high-performance vehicle like the 997 Carrera S. A rebuilt engine suggests that a significant component has been meticulously restored or replaced, potentially offering a renewed lease of life and reliability. Recent specialist servicing further underscores a commitment to maintaining the car to a high standard, which is crucial for any Porsche, especially one with a performance-oriented engine and complex systems.

Key Features and Specifications (997 Carrera S)

To provide a clearer picture, here's a comparison of key specifications between the 997.1 and 997.2 Carrera S models:

Feature997.1 Carrera S (2004-2008)997.2 Carrera S (2008-2012)
Engine3.8L Naturally Aspirated Flat-63.8L Naturally Aspirated Flat-6 (DFI)
Horsepower355 hp @ 6600 rpm385 hp @ 6500 rpm
Torque390 Nm @ 4600 rpm420 Nm @ 4400 rpm
Transmission6-speed Manual or 5-speed Tiptronic S6-speed Manual or 7-speed PDK
0-60 mph (approx.)4.3 seconds (Manual)4.1 seconds (PDK)
Top Speed (approx.)180 mph188 mph
PASM (Active Suspension)OptionalStandard

It's worth noting that the 997 generation also offered the Carrera 4S variant, which featured all-wheel drive for enhanced traction and stability, particularly in adverse weather conditions. The '4S' models offered a slightly different driving feel, with the added security of four-driven wheels, and often featured a wider body than their rear-wheel-drive counterparts.

When did the 911 Carrera 4S come out?

Is the 997 Carrera S a Good Car?

Based on its performance, engineering, design, and the enduring legacy of the 911, the Porsche 911 (997) Carrera S is unequivocally a very good car. It represents a sophisticated and potent sports car that offers a driving experience few other vehicles can match. The description of a "very good example of a practical sports car, with a rebuilt flat-six, and which presents in excellent condition for its age" is particularly appealing. The mention of a rebuilt engine, when done correctly by reputable specialists, can be a positive indicator of thorough maintenance and a commitment to preserving the car's performance and longevity. Specialist servicing further reinforces this, suggesting that the car has been looked after by individuals with the expertise to maintain such a high-performance machine.

For enthusiasts looking for a modern classic that offers exhilarating performance, engaging handling, and a significant degree of everyday usability, the 997 Carrera S is an outstanding choice. It provides a more analogue and connected driving experience than many contemporary sports cars, making it a joy to drive on both spirited weekend blasts and more relaxed journeys. The fact that it's "ready to be enjoyed on the road" implies that it's in good mechanical order and has been prepared for immediate use, a crucial factor when considering the purchase of a used performance car.

Frequently Asked Questions

When did the 997 Carrera 4S come out?

The all-wheel-drive Carrera 4S variant of the 997 generation was launched shortly after the rear-wheel-drive Carrera models, typically around mid-2005 for the 2006 model year.

What is the difference between a 997 Carrera S and a 997 Carrera 4S?

The primary difference is the drivetrain. The Carrera S is rear-wheel drive, while the Carrera 4S is all-wheel drive. The 4S models often feature a wider body and can offer enhanced traction and stability, especially in less than ideal driving conditions.

Is the 997 generation reliable?

The 997 generation is generally considered reliable, especially when properly maintained by specialists. However, like any high-performance car, regular servicing and addressing potential issues proactively are key to ensuring long-term reliability. Common areas to check include the IMS bearing (though less prone than in earlier 996 models), clutch wear, and suspension components.

What are the advantages of the 997.2 Carrera S over the 997.1?

The 997.2 Carrera S benefits from significant updates, including direct fuel injection (DFI) for increased power and efficiency, a more robust PDK transmission option, revised styling, and updated interior technology. The PASM system was also made standard on the 997.2 models.

Is a rebuilt engine a concern for a Porsche 911?

A rebuilt engine is not necessarily a concern if it has been carried out by a reputable Porsche specialist using high-quality parts. In some cases, a professionally rebuilt engine can be more robust than the original. It's essential to have documentation and details about the rebuild process and the specialists involved.

In conclusion, the Porsche 911 (997) Carrera S remains a highly desirable and capable sports car. Its blend of performance, handling, and practicality, coupled with the iconic 911 lineage, makes it a compelling choice for enthusiasts seeking a rewarding driving experience. A well-maintained example, particularly one with documented specialist servicing and a professionally rebuilt engine, represents a sound investment in automotive enjoyment.

If you want to read more articles similar to Porsche 911 (997) Carrera S: A Modern Classic, you can visit the Cars category.

Go up